Your First 90 Days as CMO: How to Align, Unite, and Win Fast

Most new marketing leaders feel pressure to fix everything at once. Mandy Hornaday shares the three priorities she anchors to in every CMO role: prioritized alignment with the CEO, getting the team rowing together, and stacking quick wins.

By Mandy Hornaday·Date·00 min·Guest
Mandy Hornaday
Guest
Loading player…
https://www.buzzsprout.com/2431600/episodes/17648568-your-first-90-days-as-cmo-how-to-align-unite-and-win-fast.js

The short answer

What's the first thing you focus on stepping into a new marketing leadership role? Most leaders try to fix everything at once, and stall. In this solo episode, roughly 90 days into a new fractional CMO role at a $500M organization, Mandy Hornaday shares the three priorities that make the biggest difference every time: prioritized alignment with the CEO, getting the whole team rowing in the same direction with a goals-based plan, and stacking low-effort, high-impact quick wins. And these aren't just onboarding moves, they're leadership habits for any season.

Key takeaways

    You can't fix everything at once. Mandy's first 90 days come down to three priorities, done in order, not a scramble to fix it all. Get prioritized alignment with the CEO. Beyond matching business goals, decide together where marketing spends the year: which solutions, segments, and geographies come first. Use a five-factor prioritization matrix. Score solutions and segments on business-vision fit, profitability, growth potential, buying friction, and existing proof, then bring the ranked view to your CEO. Build the plan around goals, not functions. Pick three to five goals for the year, give each its own roadmap and KPIs, and run goal standups so everyone knows how they plug in. Stack quick wins. Use an impact-versus-effort matrix to find low-effort, high-impact actions that build momentum and prove the hire while the long-term strategy develops.
    In this recap

    What's the first thing you focus on when you step into a new marketing leadership role? Most leaders feel pressure to fix everything at once. In this solo episode, Mandy Hornaday makes the case for doing the opposite. Roughly 90 days into a new fractional CMO role leading a 15-to-20-person team at a $500M organization, she shares the three priorities that have made the biggest difference every time she's stepped into a CMO seat, and why they work in any season, not just the first 90 days.

    What should a new CMO focus on in the first 90 days?

    Three things, in order: prioritized alignment with the CEO, getting the team rowing together, and stacking quick wins. Mandy's core warning is that everything feels urgent when you start, and trying to do it all at once is how new leaders stall.

    You can't do it all at the same time. And honestly, you shouldn't try.

    The three priorities below are the ones she anchors to every time, and she's found they re-center an existing team just as well as a new one.

    Why is prioritized alignment with the CEO the first move?

    Because without it, marketing spends its year serving whoever is loudest. When you start, everyone is making a play for marketing's time, and the team you inherit is often activity-based and reactive rather than a proactive growth partner.

    Mandy's fix goes beyond picking goals that match the business vision. She sits down with the CEO to decide, compositionally, where marketing will spend the year: which solutions to take to market, which segments and geographies to prioritize, which sales teams to work with most.

    I actually work with the CEO to say, compositionally, this is where we're going to spend our time over the next year.

    Getting that alignment early is how a marketing leader earns the credibility that Darko Socanski describes as essential with the rest of the C-suite.

    How do you build a CMO prioritization matrix?

    Score every possible solution, segment, geography, and department against five factors, then bring the ranked view to your CEO. Mandy built exactly this stepping into her current role, weighing each option on: alignment with the business vision, profitability potential, market growth opportunity over the next three to five years, buying trends and regulatory friction (healthcare and financial services are harder to reach), and existing proof points and presence like strong sales coverage and customer stories.

    None of the five is an end-all on its own, but together they let her walk back to the CEO with a strategic recommendation grounded in internal knowledge and external research. She also uses ChatGPT and other LLMs to run the market research and pressure-test how the segments rank once all the factors are in.

    It helps us make a more strategic decision around where to focus as opposed to serving the loudest person on the team.

    How do you get a marketing team rowing in the same direction?

    Break the silos by aligning the whole team to shared goals before adding other departments. Mandy consistently finds functions operating in their own lanes, each doing good work but rarely looking up at the collective, integrated impact on the business.

    Her sequence matters: get marketing itself in lockstep in the first 90 days, then bring sales, product, and customer success into the same boat. Getting your own house in order first avoids adding personalities and confusion before the core team is aligned. This is the enablement work this episode on laying the tracks digs into.

    What does a goals-based marketing plan look like versus a function-based one?

    It organizes the roadmap around a few outcomes, not around channels. Mandy says most plans she inherits are built by function, a dump of what the website, SEO, and social will each do over the year.

    I structure the marketing plan to all be centered around goals rather than to be centered around functions.

    Instead, she picks three to five major goals for the year, three for her current org, and rarely more, because a team can't meaningfully achieve more than that. Each goal gets its own section with a roadmap and KPIs tied to that goal, rather than a separate list of social or campaign metrics. The annual marketing plan guide walks through building one this way.

    How do you organize a team around goals instead of silos?

    Run goal standups, not just functional ones. Mandy takes the goals-based plan a step further and orients team collaboration around each goal, gathering everyone tied to a given outcome rather than only holding function-based calls.

    If pipeline is the goal and demand-gen campaigns are the main lever, she sets up standups around those campaigns with everyone who contributes to them. It gives clear ownership, reduces confusion, and builds far stronger collaboration than working in silos. That repeatable way of running the function is exactly what a CMO operating system is built to install.

    How do quick wins and an impact-versus-effort matrix build early trust?

    They show the C-suite fast results without abandoning the long-term plan. Mandy names the tension directly: the pressure to fix everything immediately, plus your own excitement to move fast, against the reality that real change takes time.

    Her tool is an impact-versus-effort matrix. She has each functional leader map their planned actions, then prioritize the low-effort, high-impact ones as quick wins you can do today. It builds momentum and signals to leadership that they made the right hire, while the longer-term strategy keeps developing underneath.

    How can we be creating a vision and a foundation to achieve the long-term plan while still doing the next best thing today to move the needle.

    Which first-90-day habits carry into any season of leadership?

    All three, because they're leadership habits, not onboarding tricks. Mandy closes by boiling it down: get prioritized alignment with your C-suite, get your team rowing in the same direction with a goals-based plan, and focus on incremental quick wins that build momentum and trust.

    These aren't just first 90 day strategies. They're leadership habits that will serve you well in any season of your career.

    Whether you're 90 days or three years into a role, the same moves re-center a team and create visible movement.

    Chapters & timestamps
    0:28 Why the First 90 Days Make or Break You 1:52 Priority 1: Prioritized Alignment With the CEO 3:53 The CMO Prioritization Matrix (5 Factors) 8:00 Priority 2: Get Marketing Rowing Together 9:46 Build a Goals-Based Marketing Plan 12:18 Priority 3: Incrementality and Quick Wins 15:04 Recap: Three Habits for Any Season

    Common questions

    How long does it really take a new CMO to make an impact?

    Meaningful foundations take the full first 90 days and beyond, but you can show early movement much sooner. Mandy's approach is to build the long-term strategy while deliberately landing a few low-effort, high-impact quick wins so leadership sees progress in the first three months.

    Should a new CMO align with the CEO first or the whole C-suite?

    Start with the CEO. Mandy prioritizes alignment with the CEO on where marketing will focus for the year, then extends that alignment across the rest of the C-suite and the go-to-market teams once marketing's own direction is set.

    What are the most common mistakes marketing leaders make in a new role?

    Trying to fix everything at once, inheriting an activity-based reactive team and continuing it, and serving whoever is loudest instead of the priorities that match the business vision. Mandy's three priorities are designed to counter exactly these.

    How does a fractional or interim CMO approach the first 90 days differently?

    The priorities are the same, but the clock is tighter, so alignment and quick wins matter even more. Mandy is roughly 90 days into a fractional CMO role at a $500M organization and uses the same prioritization matrix and goals-based plan she'd use in a full-time seat.

    How do you balance quick wins with long-term strategy?

    Hold both at once with an incrementality mindset. Mandy builds the long-term vision and foundation while asking each functional leader to surface low-effort, high-impact actions, so the team builds momentum today without losing sight of the year's goals.

    Guest
    About the guest

    Show full transcript

    Mandy Hornaday: What's the very first thing you focus on when you step into a new marketing leadership role? If you're like most leaders, you probably feel the pressure to fix everything at once, from campaigns to operations to team alignment. But here's the reality. You can't do it all at the same time. And honestly, you shouldn't try. Welcome to Growth Activated.

    Mandy Hornaday: I'm your host, Mandy Hornaday. And today we're talking about the first 90 days in a new leadership role. I'm personally approaching 90 days in my newest fractional CMO position, leading a team of about 15 to 20 in an organization that's about 500 million. And I have to say, I'm really loving the culture, the leadership and the company overall. But no matter how many CMO roles I've taken on, there are three priorities that always make the biggest difference for me in those first 90 days.

    Mandy Hornaday: And in this episode, I'll walk you through them so you can step into your next role with clarity, confidence, and a plan to make an immediate impact. And frankly, even if you're not currently stepping into a new role, I still think these three tips will help you re-center, realign, and see big movement in your current team. Let's get into it. Okay. So one of the most important things that I prioritize above, frankly, all else is prioritized alignment with the C-suite and really particularly the CEO.

    Mandy Hornaday: When you first start a role at a new company, everything feels like a priority, right? You're meeting all of your peers, all of the different stakeholders across the business. You're learning the sales strategy and frankly, everything feels important.

    Mandy Hornaday: There are a lot of competing priorities and a lot of people vying for marketing's time. One of the biggest things I see within marketing teams, and typically the teams that I'm taking over when I step into an organization, is that the marketing teams are really activity-based and reactive in the way that they operate, as opposed to being a strategic proactive business partner and growth partner.

    Mandy Hornaday: And frankly, it's so easy to fall into this trap. Even when you can identify it, when you step into a new organization, it's hard not to continue that trend. Especially when you have all of your new peers and the different divisions and departments making a play for marketing's time. And of course we, as new leaders, want to get on these people's good sides. We want to build strong relationships and strong rapport. And this is a common challenge that I see new leaders step into.

    Mandy Hornaday: And on the flip side, you know, as new leaders into the organization, you might be fired up. You might be really excited. You might see tons of opportunity within the marketing organization, and it might also feel overwhelming and daunting to figure out how we're going to go about it and get it all done within the next 12 months.

    Mandy Hornaday: Right? And so one of the things I anchor myself in is really the prioritized alignment with the CEO. And to me, this isn't just about choosing marketing goals that are aligned to the business goals and vision, although that is incredibly important. I actually work with the CEO to say, compositionally, this is where we're going to spend our time over the next year. These are the solutions we're going to market. These are the segments we're going to go after and prioritize.

    Mandy Hornaday: These are the sales teams that we're going to work with the most. So one of the things I did stepping into this new role, that I would encourage you to do too, is a prioritization matrix of all of the possible solutions, segments, geographies, and departments that marketing could and should be serving. And with that, I created a prioritization matrix that looked at several different factors. The first being, which are most aligned with the business vision?

    Mandy Hornaday: Where is the company going in the next several years? Are we evolving from one solution to the next? Are we evolving into new markets? Right? Are we evolving into new industries? Where does the company want to go and which segments are going to take us there? That's step number one. The second piece of the prioritization matrix that I look at is the profitability potential. Which segments have the highest profit margins?

    Mandy Hornaday: Where are we going to see the most, not only the most revenue, but the most profitability on the bottom line? That's definitely a key factor as we think about scalable, efficient growth. The third thing I look at is the market growth opportunity in that particular segment. Which segments have the highest growth potential in the next three to five years?

    Mandy Hornaday: Which ones are high growth and which ones have a potential to be stagnant or even decrease. The next thing I considered as a part of the prioritization matrix was buying trends. Are there any key buying trends or restrictions that would prevent us from being able to do our job? So for example, some of the heavily regulated industries, healthcare comes to mind, it can be harder to market to those personas and market to those accounts. They might have strict rules in place. I know financial services is another one.

    Mandy Hornaday: So think about where, where's the ease of marketing, um, going to fit well. Now, certainly this is not an end all be all. And frankly, none of these factors are. If you sell a cybersecurity product and it's really hard to get in front of cybersecurity professionals, you're going to have to work around that. Right. But if you had a choice to go after cybersecurity professionals or software engineers, software engineers are probably going to be your lower barrier to growth than cybersecurity professionals who are very hard, who oftentimes don't want to be found. So something to keep in mind.

    Mandy Hornaday: And then the last factor I considered as a part of this prioritization matrix was our proof points and our presence. So where do we already have a strong sales team or presence across the different segments or solutions or geographies? And where do we have a lot of proof, where we have successful customers, or we have customer stories to tell that are really strong and testimonials, right? It's only going to amplify our impact when we think about marketing's success factors going into a campaign.

    Mandy Hornaday: So if you haven't done this exercise before, I would highly encourage it. And it really allows you to bring the strategic mindset to the table back with your CEO and say, hey, based on everything I've learned internally, as well as the external market research in terms of what's actually happening. Here's where I feel like you're going to get the most bang for your buck out of the marketing function over the next year. And here's where we are really going to invest our time and our energy in order to be successful for the company.

    Mandy Hornaday: Now, quick note here, leverage ChatGPT or any of the LLMs to help you do this research. It can actually help you set up your prioritization matrix and conduct some deep research with market research, but it can also help you rationalize how to prioritize the segments and why after you add in all of these different factors and the inputs that you have for your particular business. And frankly, when you approach it this way, it helps us make a more strategic decision around where to focus as opposed to serving the loudest person on the team, which is sometimes the reality that many of us are familiar with.

    Mandy Hornaday: So tip number one, create prioritized alignment with your CEO specifically, and leverage a prioritization matrix to help you justify where you and your team should spend their time over the next 12 months. This has been a game changer for me.

    Mandy Hornaday: All right. Focus number two, priority number two, when I step into a new role. And this has been really top of mind for me as we're exiting the first 90 days and getting into run mode. And that's getting everyone rowing in the same direction. Another thing that's really common when I walk into a marketing organization is that every function or each of the programs seem to operate in their own silos. And the team members themselves may be doing excellent jobs within their particular area, but so often the team isn't looking up and out in terms of what is the collective and integrated impact we are making on the organization.

    Mandy Hornaday: One of the biggest ways that I culturally try and shift from this silo operations into a fluid empowered team is that I structure the marketing plan to all be centered around goals rather than to be centered around functions. And so what I mean by this is a lot of times when I walk in and I see the existing marketing plans, it's by function, right? It's here's what we're going to do for the website. Here's what SEO is going to do. Here's what social media is going to do over the next year.

    Mandy Hornaday: And it's very, it's a very like programmatic approach. Um, and honestly, just a dump of everything that we're going to do into one big roadmap. That's the reality of most of the marketing plans that I see when I step into an organization. And how I flip that on its head is I build a marketing plan that's goals oriented and goals forward as opposed to program and function forward. And so what that looks like is,

    Mandy Hornaday: I will choose anywhere from three to five major marketing goals over the next 12 months. In this instance, for this org, we have three main marketing goals, but I've also done upwards of five in the past. I typically don't do more than that because realistically we're not going to be able to achieve anything meaningful more than five most of the time.

    Mandy Hornaday: But once I've identified those three goals, the entire marketing roadmap is centered around those three goals. And so each goal has a section and each section includes a roadmap specific to achieving that goal, as well as KPIs specific to achieving that goal. As opposed to, here's my social media KPIs, here's my campaign KPIs, right? It's really centered around what are the KPIs that will tell us that we've made movement and we are achieving the goal that we've set out to.

    Mandy Hornaday: Now, I personally even take it a step further than this. I will actually orient the team collaboration around these goals. So rather than having functional calls and standups, although those are powerful too, feel free to continue doing those, but I'll have goal standups. So what are the major projects, initiatives and programs that tie directly into the goal that we are trying to accomplish. And that's how I orient the team. For example, if driving a certain amount of pipeline is our goal and one of the biggest ways we're going to move the needle on that, our demand generation campaigns, then we will set up team standups around those campaigns that involve everybody who is tied into achieving the success with that campaign.

    Mandy Hornaday: And so what I've personally found is this just really helps connect the entire team and their roles and their responsibilities to the actual goal and end game that we're trying to accomplish within the marketing function that year. It provides clear ownership, it reduces confusion, and it creates a lot stronger collaboration than operating in silos.

    Mandy Hornaday: And my last tip here is that I always start with aligning marketing and getting everyone rowing in the same direction, right? Are we on the same bus going to the same destination? Once I've achieved that and I feel like marketing is really in lockstep after the first 90 days, at that point, I'll look to bring in other departments and make sure we're rowing on the same boat as well, right? So if you add sales into the equation or product or customer success, we certainly all want to be rowing in the same direction as a go-to-market organization, absolutely. But I try and get my own house in order before I start adding in a ton of more personalities and confusion to the mix.

    Mandy Hornaday: Okay, and the number three thing that I always focus on in the first 90 days is centered around the idea of incrementality and quick wins. So when you're stepping into a new organization, there can be this intense pressure to fix it all, right? The moment you walk in the door. Or the CEO asking when will we start creating a lot of pipeline? And on the flip side, we ourselves can be incredibly excited and jazzed up about everything we want to accomplish over the next year. And we, depending on your own personality, want to be accomplishing things very quickly.

    Mandy Hornaday: And so for me, one of the things that I've always prioritized in the first 90 days is this incrementality mindset. How can we be creating a vision and a foundation to achieve the long-term plan while still doing the next best thing today to move the needle. And so one of the ways in practice that I like to do this is when I have my different functional leaders all think about what their functions are going to do to help us achieve the goals and they build out their plans, I'll then ask them to use an impact versus effort matrix to identify low effort, high impact actions.

    Mandy Hornaday: So if you imagine the X axis being effort level, so low effort on the left, high effort on the right, and impact being the Y axis, so low impact on the bottom and high impact on the top, we really want to be choosing the activities or the tactics or the projects that are going to be low effort, high impact. Those are your quick wins, and those are the things that you can do today and not wait to see success, right? And we all want to see some success in our first 90 days. You want your C-suite team to know that they made the right choice and they're starting to see some of the trickle effects of having you in, even though your job is certainly to build a long-term strategy and be able to manage to that strategy.

    Mandy Hornaday: So creating this culture and focus of incrementality and quick wins is one of the ways that I create this best of both worlds. We're building momentum while working towards longer term changes. And I'm encouraging the team and supporting the team to think about their functions in terms of short term and long term.

    Mandy Hornaday: Awesome. So I don't know about you, but the first 90 days for me at a new role just completely fly by. I'm having a lot of fun right now. Um, but when I step back and look at what are really the meaningful things I'm putting into practice for the marketing team to build a strong foundation over the next year and beyond, they really boil down to these three things for me. So number one, getting prioritized alignment with your C-suite. The prioritized piece is incredibly important. Yes, you want to get aligned with your C-suite and your CEO, but you need to also make sure that you're prioritizing your efforts within that alignment.

    Mandy Hornaday: Because so often everyone wants to do everything at once and we just know we won't be successful if that's the case. Number two, getting your team rowing in the same direction. No more operating in silos. Our teams are meant to be fluid and empowered with how they approach their work. So start with a goals-based plan that everyone knows how they exactly plug into the plan in order to achieve the goals that the department is committing to for the next year.

    Mandy Hornaday: And third, but not least, focus on those incremental and quick wins that build momentum and trust quickly. Make sure that by the end of your first 90 days, your C-suite is not questioning why they've brought you in and they're already starting to feel the ripple impact of your role and your leadership. And as I mentioned at the beginning, these aren't just first 90 day strategies. They're leadership habits that will serve you well in any season of your career. So even if you have been at your company for six months or a year or three years, if any of these three focus areas will help you, please take what you can and put it into practice within your team.

    Mandy Hornaday: And if you're heading into annual planning and want a partner to help you set your vision, build a strategic roadmap and strengthen your executive presence, check out my Lead Like a CMO Strategy Planning Sprint. You can visit growthactivated.com to learn more and set up some time to speak with me. It's a high impact way to go into planning season, clear, confident, and ready to lead. And as always in the meantime, keep activating growth for yourself and your company. See you next time.

    GA
    The CMO Operating System

    Stop running on instinct. Install the system.

    Run marketing like a business, prove its value, and scale without burning out.

    August 12, 2025
    18 min